Saturday, January 12, 2013

Want to help out a writer friend? Give 'em four stars!

One thing that astounds me about Goodreads is the number of five-star reviews that so many books have. I don't know about you but I can count on my fingers (and maybe my toes) the books I would give five stars to. A book has to have a profound effect on me to give it five stars. I would give Arthur Golden five stars for truly making me believe he was a 15-year-old Japanese peasant-turned-geisha. Or JK Rowling for getting people (not just kids) reading again. CS Lewis, for creating a world that I wanted to find. Jane Austen, for her pioneering and playful view of women and their roles in society.

So when I see a new YA or MG book that has tons of five-star reviews, the first thing that pops into my head is how many friends that author must have. Maybe that isn't fair, but I find it hard to believe that the book could be so very perfect that everybody would give it five stars. As writers, we know how hard it is to craft a good book, let alone a perfect one. Five-star reviews seem too good to be true.

As I scroll through the five-star reviews and then come to a two-star review, which do you think I read? That's right. The two-star. Because I think it might be more honest. When I'm looking for a book, I don't want to read "It's perfect" twenty times. I want an honest opinion of its strengths and weaknesses.

I think it is wonderful that we rally around the newly-published and support them by giving reviews. But just as a "It's great" beta report isn't all that helpful, an "It's perfect!" review isn't helpful either.

So if you have a friend, a critique partner, or a favorite author who has a book coming out, think hard about your review and how it is perceived by those looking at the reviews. Your honest four-star review could go much further in selling that book than the shiny five-star one.


  1. I have to agree! I can't believe a large amount of 5-star reviews some extremely new books/authors get. And, if someone gives a book 4 stars, I'm still likely to read it.

  2. Very good point, I shall bear that in mind :o)

  3. Thank you for sharing in this article
    I can learn a lot and could also be a reference
    I hope to read the next your article updates.

    Di zaman yang modern dan serba maju ini, kebutuhan akan alat bantu wanita sangat di perlukan oleh kaum pria dan wanitaalat sex pria
    yang berfungsi untuk memberi rasa sensasi dan kenikmatan yang berlebih obat perangsang wanitayang berfungsi untuk memberi rasa sensasi dan kenikmatan yang berlebih apotik jual obat perangsang
    kami juga menyediakan obat untuk gaerah wanita di toko obat perangsang wanita malang online dan offline shop terbaik toko alat sex pria wanita malang produk populer saat ini adalah toko Jual Vimax Asli kota malang
    apabila anda mempunyai keluhan tentang ukuran alat vital sebaiknya anda menggunakan vimax asli apotik jual vimax asli siap melayani pemesanan keseluruh indonesia